DSPs vs. FPGAs for multiprocessing
February 04, 2008 -- dspdesignline.com
Life used to be easy. If you were working on a multi-processor signal processing application, you would write down the requirements, check the specs of the devices on offer from the major DSP vendors, and just pick the chip that suited best.
Times have changed, and today's engineers are blessed with far more choice. The big FPGA vendors have stepped up their offerings for signal processing, and choosing the best solution can seem complex.
For distributed applications, the choice of interconnect technology can also obviously have a crucial effect on the overall solution. Crunching the data is all very well, but your system needs to have the right interfaces to move it around between the different processors, and off-load the results. What do the DSP and FPGA vendors have to offer in this area?
In this article, we'll look at what's available for multi-processor systems (which inevitably tends to mean the high-performance end of the market), and how you can make the best choice between DSP, FPGA or a hybrid mixture of the two. We'll look fairly briefly at issues involved in the two types of chip, but concentrate more on system-level factors.
For high-performance signal processing applications, of course there are other options beyond DSPs and FPGAs. Massively parallel processors from vendors like picoChip are one alternative, but unfortunately often require the use of the vendor's proprietary toolset. (See Analysis: BDTI benchmarks picoChip PC102.) ASICs and ASSPs are also well-suited to certain signal processing tasks, but their high up-front costs rule them out except in high volume applications.
To read the full article, click here
Related Semiconductor IP
- MACsec Engine optimized for 10Base-T1S/T1L applications
- Dual Port, Voltage Scaling Register File Compiler on GF22FDX+
- Single Port, Voltage Scaling, High Speed SRAM Memory Compiler on GF22FDX+
- I3C Full Controller / Target
- I3C HCI Host Controller
Related Articles
- Use ESL synthesis techniques to replace dedicated DSPs with FPGAs
- Accelerate system performance with hybrid multiprocessing and FPGAs
- High-Performance DSPs -> Voice control enhances appliance apps
- High-Performance DSPs -> Overcoming hot spots in Viterbi equalization
Latest Articles
- PULSAR-V: I/O-Aware Post-Update Attestation for RISC-V
- PVTSizing 2.0: A Fast and Reliable Analog Circuit Sizing Operator for Agentic EDA Workflows
- An Agentic Python Framework for LLM-Driven UVM Testbench Synthesis with Closed-Loop Compiler Feedback
- Reconfiguring System-Level Protection Through Bounded Delegation in RISC-V MCUs
- SkipLane: Write-Once, Conflict-Free Accumulation for Zero-Skipping CNN Engines on FPGAs